Wild pigs and boars can be taken on with a .44 Magnum. And yes, carbines beat pistols. 10mm vs .357 Magnum for Bear Protection in Alaska 44 Magnum Desert Eagle L6 Ballistics Test with Underwood XP and 180gr JHP Review 9mm vs. 40 S&W vs. 357 Sig vs. 45 Auto vs 10mm Liberty … Both 44 Rem Mag and 45 LC are viable self-defense rounds but in our testing, the performance of 44 Magnum gets the nod. Mature bears weigh anywhere from 150 pounds to over 1000 based on species and geographical location. The other truth is the terminal effect on either an animal or human doesn’t change much between those two numbers. But then again, why not? Somebody else will have to opine on the .45 LC in the Vaquero - I know that high-power .45 LC loads have been reported to be effective on everything from squirrels to T-rex (not sure about the reliability of that last report, though), but I've heard … For those who want to pass on the recoil of the .454, the Ruger Alaskan also comes in .44 Magnum. 45 LC vs. 44 Mag: Carry Capacity If you are using either cartridge for self defense or home protection, you are likely concerned with the total load capacity of the round. Single-action vs Double-action. The first is their bullet diameters. The … The Henry .45-70 can handle all factory loaded .45-70 ammunition intended for use in lever action rifles or equivalent handloads and it is very smooth in operation. or a big-bore in .45-70 Gov't or .450 … It all depends on the circumstances of the … Should be plenty to take a black bear down or at least it think twice about attacking still. After all, it’s guns, ammo, Paul Harrell, and my favorite cartridge of all time, the 44 mag. There are three important things to take away when you put the 10mm and the 44 Mag side by side. Though .44 Magnum is often considered the minimum cartridge for a bear-defense gun, that isn't necessarily the case. For something different, try a handgun. Most of us that work in the AK Back Country will carry bear spray and a firearm (12-gauge or .44 Mag). Automatic option for black bear other than a10mm that youll never carry any other time. The story convinced me not to carry any less than a .44 mag in big bear country. 10mm vs. 44 Mag Size Comparison The other main difference is the size. Brown Bear Stopping Power 45 auto vs 44 magnum 02-05-2009, 09:56. 44 Mag with the hottest load that I can hit with. vs. 700 ft-lbs.). Mag., 454 Casull, 460 S&W Mag. Chambered in rifles, they’re even better. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .338 Winchester Magnum vs .45-70 Government ammo rounds. While not bullet proof, bears can take enormous punishment and still live long enough to end you. .41 Mag. jleyring, Aug 3, 2010 #13. gun guy Member. Also seen in the class was the Taurus Raging Bull revolver in .454 Casull. If you're think about them, hell, even a .44 Mag. is marginal for stopping a charging Grizz or Brown. I love a nice spring black bear … vs. .44 Mag. Not all .44 Mag handgun rounds will function the same in a rifle as they do not get the same penetration power. Later I had an 18" barreled rifle built on a pre 64 Win Mod 70 action, chambered for 458 Win Mag. 10mm vs 44 Magnum Cartridge Comparison. Let me differ from my brethren. When bear were know to be an issue I carried my Mossberg 500 12 ga. with slugs also. Although he recommends "anything .30-06 and up," like many Alaskans he is a fan of the big bore guns: .375 H&H, .375 Ruger, .338 Win. It sports an 18" barrel sans ports and comes standard with a ghost ring rear sight. Gonna do that with a 45LC or .44 mag? These are big beasts, and ornery, too. Bear Defense: … I like both single-action and double-action revolvers for hunting, however when carried for self-defense from bear attack, there is a pretty strong consensus that the double-action revolver is the better choice. I'd be curious as to what they chrono out of a four or six inch revolver. In bear country, I would do the research, but initially I would think that 12 gauge slugs or a rifle in .45-70 govt. vs. .338 Federal vs. .45-70 Govt. Light to carry, manageable recoil, do a quick reload of 125jhp and your good for CCW. I will use them on black bear in the fall in my .45-70 lever gun. In this in-depth comparison between the 45-70 vs 30-30 rounds, our team chooses the 30-30 round because it has significantly reduced drawback and less ammo drop, giving it a flatter trajectory. I noted that Nelson liked open sights for bear-defense situations­ — again, this is short-range work. This is particularly true if you're most concerned about defending yourself from a black bear as opposed to a much larger brown or grizzly bear. Which one of these popular rounds will be named the best all-around black bear hunting cartridge By Ron Spomer October 11, 2019 Guns